Part of the Finger Lakes Hub • See also: Seneca Lake 35 wineries 30 min west • Keuka Lake Dr Frank 40 min west • Ithaca 10 waterfalls • 15 min north of Ithaca
First wine trail in US — 1983 — 11 stops on 38-mile Cayuga Lake. Swedish Hill most awarded, Thirsty Owl best restaurant, Knapp oldest 1984, plus cider + mead + distillery. Tastings $10-20, 5 max per day, Ithaca base. Full guide below.
Why Cayuga is First: 1983 History & 38-Mile Lake
Seneca gets hype for Riesling, but Cayuga invented wine trail concept in US. 5 wineries in 1983 lobbied state, created signage, map, passport. Now 16 stops: 12 wineries + 2 cideries + 1 meadery + 1 distillery + farm market. Longest lake 38 miles = 76-mile loop, don't do full loop in one day.
- 1983: First organized wine trail in US — Americana Vineyards, Knapp, Lucas, etc petitioned NY to allow signage on Route 89/90
- 38 miles long: From Ithaca south (Cornell) to Seneca Falls north (Women's Rights Park) — college town to historic canal
- Most diverse: Only trail with mead (Eagle Crest), cider (Blackduck), distillery (Myer Farm), farm market (Lively Run)
- Quiet vs Seneca: 11 Wineries vs 35, less traffic, more locals, Ithaca food scene best in Finger Lakes
Cayuga Lake Wineries by Location: Ithaca to Seneca Falls Map
Cayuga runs north-south, Route 89 west side, Route 90 east side. South end = Ithaca, north end = Seneca Falls. Most wineries mid-lake Romulus/Ovid. Do south half or north half in one day, 5 max.
🗺 West Side Route 89: Ithaca → Seneca Falls (7 wineries)
- Swedish Hill Vineyard - 4565 State Route 414 Romulus, $15 - Most awarded in NY, best sparkling, Viking tasting room
- Knapp Winery & Vineyard Restaurant - 2770 County Rd 128 Romulus, $15 - Oldest 1984, best restaurant, farm-to-table $20-35
- Goose Watch Winery - 5480 Route 89 Romulus, $12 - Best views, lakefront deck, 30 wines
- Thirsty Owl Wine Company - 6799 Elm Beach Rd Ovid, $15 - Best food + bistro $18-30, lake views, wood-fired pizza
- Buttonwood Grove Winery - 5986 State Route 89 Romulus, $10 - Best budget, lake views, $8 tastings weekdays
- Hosmer Winery - 7020 Route 89 Ovid, $12 - Best Riesling on Cayuga, 70 acres, family-owned since 1985
- Lucas Vineyards - 3862 County Rd 150 Interlaken, $10 - Oldest family, best reds, Tug Boat Red famous
🗺 East Side Route 90: Seneca Falls → Ithaca (4 wineries + cider + mead)
- Americana Vineyards - 4367 E Covert Rd Interlaken, $10 - One of original 5 in 1983, Crystal Lake Cafe, best lunch $12-22
- Long Point Winery - 1485 Lake Road Aurora, $10 - Best architecture, Greek Revival barn, small production
- Montezuma Winery & Hidden Marsh Distillery - 2981 Auburn Rd Seneca Falls, $10 - Mead + fruit wines + distillery, most diverse tasting
- Varick Winery & Vineyard - 5102 State Route 89 Romulus, $10 - Best sunset deck, family-owned
🗺 Interactive Map - 11 Wineries First Trail 1983
38 miles: South = Ithaca Cornell, North = Seneca Falls. West side Route 89 = 8 wineries, East side Route 90 = 8 wineries + cider + mead. First trail in US 1983. Zoom for directions.
Top 6 Cayuga Lake Wineries: Best Picks by Category
| Winery | Best For | Tasting Fee | Side |
|---|---|---|---|
| Swedish Hill Vineyard | Most Awarded, Best Sparkling | $15 | West |
| Thirsty Owl Wine Co | Best Restaurant + Pizza + Views | $15 | West |
| Knapp Winery | Oldest 1984 + Best Farm Restaurant | $15 | West |
| Hosmer Winery | Best Riesling on Cayuga | $12 | West |
| Americana Vineyards | Original 1983 + Best Cafe Lunch | $10 | East |
| Montezuma Winery | Mead + Distillery + Most Diverse | $10 | East |
Tasting Fees, Hours & First Trail History
- Fees: $10-20 avg $12, waived with $25-30 bottle purchase. Swedish Hill/Knapp/Thirsty Owl $15, Americana/Buttonwood $10
- Hours: 10am-5pm daily, 6pm Fri-Sat summer. Winter 11am-5pm, some closed Jan-Feb Tue-Wed
- History: 1983 first wine trail in US — Americana, Knapp, Lucas, etc. Created trail passport, state signage. Now 16 stops including cider, mead, distillery
- DD Tips: 5 wineries max = 1.5 bottles. Use Ithaca rideshare or Cayuga Wine Trail shuttle $65pp weekends May-Oct
Food Stops Between Wineries: Ithaca to Aurora
- Ithaca South: Ithaca Beer Co taproom $12-20, Moosewood Restaurant vegetarian famous $18-28, Coltivare farm-to-table $25-40
- Mid-Lake: Knapp Winery Restaurant $20-35 best farm-to-table, Thirsty Owl Bistro $18-30 wood-fired pizza lake views, Americana Crystal Lake Cafe $12-22
- Aurora North: Fargo Bar & Grill $15-25 historic inn, Aurora Inn Dining Room $30-50 lakefront fine dining
Where to Stay: Ithaca vs Aurora vs Seneca Falls
- Ithaca South: Best for food + Cornell + waterfalls. La Tourelle Resort $200-350, Hilton Garden Inn $150-220, dorms $80-120 summer
- Aurora Mid-Lake: Quiet, historic, walk to 2 wineries. Aurora Inn $250-400 lakefront, E.B. Morgan House $180-280
- Seneca Falls North: Historic canal + Women's Rights Park. Gould Hotel $180-280, Hampton Inn $130-180
1-Day Cayuga Wine Trail Itinerary: 5 Wineries + Ithaca
- 10:00 AM - Start Ithaca south, Swedish Hill 4565 Rt 414 Romulus $15 - Most awarded, sparkling, Viking room
- 11:00 AM - Knapp Winery 2770 County Rd 128 $15 - Oldest 1984, farm vineyard
- 12:00 PM - Lunch at Knapp Restaurant or Thirsty Owl Bistro 6799 Elm Beach Rd $18-30 - Best pizza + lake views
- 1:30 PM - Thirsty Owl $15 - Deck tasting, 20 wines
- 2:30 PM - Hosmer Winery 7020 Rt 89 $12 - Best Riesling Cayuga
- 3:30 PM - Americana Vineyards 4367 E Covert Rd $10 - Original 1983, Crystal Lake Cafe, buy bottles
- 5:00 PM - Back to Ithaca, Moosewood dinner $18-28 or Coltivare $25-40, walk Commons
- Stay: La Tourelle $200-350 or Hilton Garden $150-220
Rules: 5 max, 10am-5pm, $10-20 avg, waived $30 bottle. Shuttle $65pp weekends.
Day Trips: Seneca & Keuka Wine Trails + Ithaca Waterfalls
Cayuga is central — 30 min to Seneca, 40 min to Keuka, 15 min to Ithaca 10 waterfalls.
- Seneca Lake 35 wineries 30 min west: Longest deep, best Riesling, east vs west drives. Seneca Lake Wine Trail Map Guide - 35 wineries, interactive maps
- Keuka Lake 8 wineries 40 min west: Y-shaped, Dr Frank 1962 birthplace, Bully Hill views. Keuka Lake Dr Frank & Bully Hill Guide - Y-shape map
- Ithaca Waterfalls 15 min south: 10 falls, Buttermilk Falls $10 parking, Treman. Ithaca Waterfalls Guide
Search Syr-Area
Cayuga Lake Wine Trail - FAQ
Why is Cayuga Lake the first wine trail in the US?
In 1983, 5 wineries — Americana, Knapp, Lucas and others — petitioned NY to allow signage on Route 89/90, created the first organized wine trail map and passport in the US. Now 16 stops: 12 wineries + 2 cideries + 1 meadery + 1 distillery + farm market.
East vs West Side Cayuga — which should I drive?
West Side Route 89: 8 wineries, Swedish Hill, Knapp, Thirsty Owl, Hosmer, Goose Watch, Buttonwood. East Side Route 90: Americana, Long Point, Montezuma, Varick, cider + mead. Don't do full 76-mile loop in one day — pick south half or north half, 5 max.
How many Cayuga wineries can you visit in one day?
5 wineries max per day. 5 wineries = about 1.5 bottles in tastes. Use DD or Cayuga Wine Trail shuttle $65pp weekends May-Oct. Tasting $10-20 avg $12, waived with $25-30 bottle. Hours 10am-5pm, 6pm Fri-Sat summer.
What is the best Riesling on Cayuga Lake?
Hosmer Winery — 7020 Route 89 Ovid, $12 tasting, 70 acres, family-owned since 1985, best Riesling on Cayuga. Also try Swedish Hill for sparkling, Lucas for reds.
Where should I stay — Ithaca, Aurora, or Seneca Falls?
Ithaca south: La Tourelle $200-350, best food + Cornell + waterfalls. Aurora mid-lake: Aurora Inn $250-400 lakefront, quiet, walk to 2 wineries. Seneca Falls north: Gould Hotel $180-280, historic canal + Women's Rights Park.
Can I do Cayuga, Seneca, and Keuka in one trip?
Yes — 3-day trip: Cayuga Day 1 from Ithaca, Seneca Day 2 30 min west 35 wineries, Keuka Day 3 40 min west Dr Frank + Bully Hill. Cayuga is central base — 15 min to Ithaca waterfalls.